Heaters Tested
50,000+readers helped113products reviewed8 yearsof consumer researchUpdatedmonthly

Best Smart Thermostats for Heating Control: What We Found After Installing Them at Home

Our editors are working through the top smart thermostats right now — installing each on real furnaces and boilers, living with the apps, and tracking whether the scheduling actually changes what we pay to heat our homes. Here's what we evaluate and how to get our verdict the moment it lands.

Rankings determined by testing data, performance, and user feedback — not manufacturer payments.

  • Published—
  • Last updated—

Is your heating system running full-tilt while you're at work, or blasting heat at midnight because nobody thought to adjust the schedule?

Are you still using a programmable thermostat you set up three winters ago and haven't touched since — one that heats an empty house the same as a full one?

If either of those sounds familiar, a smart thermostat is probably the single most practical upgrade you can make to your home heating. Our editors are currently living with the top five models — installed on real furnaces and boilers, in real homes — to find out which ones actually deliver on their promise of lower bills, smarter scheduling and apps that don't make you want to throw your phone across the room. Here's what we're evaluating, and how to hear our verdict first.

Important note about how we compare:Heaters Tested is an editorial publication that earns a small commission when readers purchase via our affiliate links. This never influences our ratings — we use the same evaluation approach and criteria across every product.About our methodology

We're currently testing the top 5 Smart Thermostats on the market.

Our editors have installed each model on their own furnaces and boilers — in houses ranging from a 1920s farmhouse to a modern semi-detached — and are living with them through a full run of cold weather. We're grading each thermostat on how it handles real-life routines: busy mornings, away days, and the kind of schedule that shifts week to week.

No manufacturer briefings, no showroom demos. Just day-to-day use in the rooms where we actually live, with an eye on what the heating bill does over time.

What we evaluate

  • App quality on iOS & Android — how easy it is to adjust schedules, check history and use remote control day to day.
  • Scheduling flexibility & learning — whether the thermostat adapts to your actual routine or needs constant manual nudging.
  • Compatibility with common heating systems — furnaces, boilers, heat pumps and multi-stage setups we've connected ourselves.
  • Real-world bill impact — whether running the thermostat for a full season produces a noticeable drop in heating costs compared with a standard programmable model.

Get the verdict when it's ready

Our editors are running hands-on evaluations now. Drop your email below to be notified the moment our verdict lands.

Subscribe — get the verdict first→

We'll email you the moment our smart thermostat rankings are published — no spam, unsubscribe any time.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I look for in a smart thermostat for home heating?
Focus on four things: compatibility with your existing furnace or boiler, app quality on your phone (iOS and Android), scheduling flexibility so the heat matches your actual routine, and whether the thermostat has a learning mode that adjusts over time. A good thermostat pays for itself in bill savings within a heating season or two.
Can a smart thermostat actually lower my heating bill?
In our experience, yes — meaningfully so. The biggest gains come from setback scheduling (dropping the temperature when you're asleep or away) and geofencing that stops heating an empty house. Our reviewers have noticed noticeable drops in their monthly gas and electric bills after switching from a basic programmable thermostat to a learning smart model.
Are smart thermostats compatible with all heating systems?
Most smart thermostats work with standard forced-air furnaces and heat pumps, but compatibility with older systems — including boilers, radiant floor heat, and multi-stage systems — varies by model. Always check the manufacturer's compatibility checker using your current wiring before buying. Some systems need a common wire (C-wire) that older homes may not have.
How hard is it to install a smart thermostat yourself?
For most forced-air systems, a DIY swap takes about 30 minutes: photograph your old wiring, remove the old thermostat, connect the labeled wires to the new terminals and follow the in-app setup guide. Our reviewers have installed several without calling a technician. That said, if you have a boiler or radiant system, or your wiring looks unusual, it's worth having an HVAC tech handle it.
Do I need a smart thermostat if I already have a programmable one?
It depends on how often you actually program it. Most people set a programmable thermostat once and never touch it again — which means it heats the house the same way on a school holiday as on a regular Tuesday. Smart thermostats with learning or geofencing fix that automatically, which is where the real bill savings come from. If you're disciplined about reprogramming seasonally, a basic programmable thermostat can work fine, but most of us aren't.
See #1 Pick